Top Five: Week in Review | ODPEM, BOJ, COP31, Shenzhen, ICJ

You are currently viewing Top Five: Week in Review | ODPEM, BOJ, COP31, Shenzhen, ICJ
This Week's Top Five: Jamaica & the World, week ending November 21, 2026. Graphic: cbeharie.com.

Good morning, and welcome to this Saturday’s Top Five. Each week we step back from the daily rush of headlines to look at the issues that carried the most weight, and at what they could mean for Jamaica, the Caribbean and the wider world.

This was a week about trust and the systems that are supposed to earn it. At home, an Auditor General’s report on how the Office of Disaster Preparedness and Emergency Management (ODPEM) handled Hurricane Melissa donations set off a political storm, and the prime minister signaled that the agency itself may be remade. The Bank of Jamaica raised interest rates for the second time in two months, warning that prices could stay too high until late 2027.

Abroad, nearly 200 countries at the COP31 climate summit in Türkiye spent the week arguing over whether the words “fossil fuels” belong in their final deal, a question that matters enormously to islands like ours. In Shenzhen, the leaders of the United States, China and Russia sat at one table for the first time, and came away with a short declaration and few breakthroughs. And in The Hague, the World Court did something it had never done before: it found a state responsible for genocide.

Here are the week’s top five.

1. The ODPEM Audit: Hurricane Melissa Relief Under the Microscope

What happened

On Tuesday, November 17, Auditor General Pamela Monroe Ellis tabled a 60-page compliance audit in the House of Representatives examining how ODPEM managed donations after Hurricane Melissa struck in October 2025. It is the fourth report in her office’s Melissa series, and the Jamaica Gleaner reported ahead of its tabling that it also looked at how the Jamaica Constabulary Force handled donated equipment.

The headline finding concerned a donation account set aside for roof repairs and semi-permanent housing. According to the audit, ODPEM spent J$45.1 million from that account on handling costs, including about J$33 million to clear goods consigned to third parties, a use for which auditors found no documented authority. The Gleaner reported the Auditor General’s central conclusion that ODPEM was “unable to demonstrate that all donations received were adequately identified, recorded, valued, and reported.”

Horizontal bar chart showing how J$45.1 million from ODPEM's Hurricane Melissa donation account was spent: J$32.97 million to clear goods for third parties, J$5.7 million for goods meant for the Government, J$4.6 million in charges not matched to any shipment, and J$1.8 million for warehouse rental and utilities.
Most of the money taken from the housing donation account went to clearing goods for private third parties, according to the audit. Graphic: cbeharie.com. Data: Auditor General’s Department, via the Jamaica Gleaner.

The report went further. ODPEM said it had received J$6.3 billion in in-kind donations by July 2026, but auditors could not verify that total, and about J$4.8 billion of it was consigned to third parties rather than the government, with no proof of handover. The Jamaica Observer reported that auditors also found 359 boxes of crackers past their best-before dates and about 200 bags of rice infested with weevils, still in storage months later, along with 15 unopened and unrecorded containers in a warehouse.

The government’s response

ODPEM’s Director General, Commander Alvin Gayle, pushed back at a post-Cabinet press briefing on Wednesday. He insisted that “no monies have been unaccounted for,” the Jamaica Information Service reported, while acknowledging that the third-party payments fell outside their approved purpose and saying the account would be reimbursed. The Observer reported his account that 169 donated prefabricated houses from China had been distributed and 31 remained in ODPEM’s custody; the auditors had been able to verify only those 31.

Prime Minister Andrew Holness, speaking in Trelawny on Thursday, called the findings concerning but not surprising. He said some issues were easily explained and should not have been included, and that the decision to use the housing funds belonged to ODPEM’s management. “That’s not my decision,” he said, according to the Gleaner. On Friday, the Gleaner reported that Holness sees the audit as an opening to push through long-recommended reforms, including permanent leadership and a possible rebranding as a National Resilience Authority. No timeline was given.

The political fight

The Opposition was not persuaded. Opposition Leader Mark Golding said Holness must take responsibility, since ODPEM was moved into the Office of the Prime Minister after the hurricane. “The failure happened on his watch,” Golding said, the Observer reported, adding that the People’s National Party (PNP) would demonstrate next week. Government senator Abka Fitz-Henley hit back, calling the criticism political gamesmanship and alleging that people linked to the PNP held senior ODPEM posts and were under investigation, the Gleaner reported. The PNP has denied that a former senior ODPEM employee was a party member, according to the Observer. These are competing claims, and none has been proven.

ODPEM had already referred the matter of missing relief inventory to law enforcement in September, and the agency stressed that the referral is not a finding that any staff member committed a crime, the Gleaner reported.

What this could mean (analysis)

Disaster relief runs on trust. People give, at home and across the diaspora, because they believe their help will reach a family without a roof. When records cannot show where goods went, the damage is not only financial; it can make donors hesitate the next time a storm comes. A restructured agency may help, but credibility will depend on clear answers about who authorized what, and on whether the same problems flagged in a 2024 audit are finally fixed.

What to watch next week

Watch for the PNP’s planned demonstration, any hearings by Parliament’s public accounts committees, progress in the law enforcement investigation, and details of the proposed National Resilience Authority. The audit also set deadlines, beginning November 30 for an assessment of the infested food stocks.

2. Money Gets Dearer: The Bank of Jamaica Raises Rates Again

What happened

On Wednesday, November 18, the Bank of Jamaica (BOJ) announced that its Monetary Policy Committee had voted unanimously to raise the policy rate by half a percentage point, from 6.00 percent to 6.50 percent, effective Thursday. It was the second straight increase, following a September move from 5.50 to 6.00 percent. In its press release, the Bank of Jamaica warned that inflation “could remain above the target range until late 2027.”

The bank’s target range is 4 to 6 percent. October inflation came in at 8.2 percent, down slightly from 8.6 percent in September but above target for a fifth straight month, according to the BOJ. The Rio Times reported that food prices rose 10.9 percent over the year and transport 15 percent, citing figures from the Statistical Institute of Jamaica.

Line chart showing the Bank of Jamaica policy rate falling from 6 percent in early 2025 to 5.5 percent in February 2026, then rising to 6 percent in September and 6.5 percent in November 2026, while headline inflation climbed from 2.9 percent in October 2025 to a peak of 8.6 percent in September 2026 and 8.2 percent in October, above the 4 to 6 percent target range.
Inflation has run above the BOJ’s 4 to 6 percent target since June, prompting two rate increases. Graphic: cbeharie.com. Data: Bank of Jamaica; STATIN figures as cited by the BOJ and The Rio Times.

Why prices are rising

The BOJ pointed to several pressures at once: higher global commodity prices linked to conflicts in the Middle East and between Russia and Ukraine, rising inflation expectations among businesses, food prices pushed up by a strengthening El Niño, and government spending on post-Melissa reconstruction. The bank now expects inflation to peak in the March 2027 quarter. It may dip briefly into the target range in December, because prices jumped after the hurricane a year earlier, but the bank expects that to be temporary. Back in September, it had hoped for a return to target by mid-2027.

There was one hopeful line for borrowers. The committee said the increases so far should be adequate to bring inflation back in time, which Mayberry Investments read as a sign the hiking cycle may be close to its end.

What it means for households

For ordinary Jamaicans, the effects arrive through loans. UWI economist Andre Haughton described the trade-off between fighting inflation and protecting growth as a tug of war. “Higher interest rates make loans more expensive,” he told the Gleaner, which noted that banks usually pass increases on to mortgages, car loans and business credit. The Observer spoke with mortgage holders who are already stretched, including one who said she was “maxed out” and another whose monthly payment is about J$40,000 higher than four years ago. No commercial bank had announced new loan rates by the end of the week.

Savers, by contrast, may earn a little more on Jamaican-dollar deposits and short-term investments. The exchange rate was stable, at about J$159 to the US dollar.

The bigger picture

Jamaica’s broader record still draws praise. Former finance minister Nigel Clarke, now a Deputy Managing Director at the International Monetary Fund, presented Jamaica as a model of reform at a conference in Brazil, noting that public debt fell from about 135 percent of GDP in 2013 to about 62 percent at the end of 2024. “The credibility built over years of reform helped keep inflation expectations anchored,” he said, the Gleaner reported. Earlier this month, the Observer reported that the IMF urged the government to keep current spending tight even as it rebuilds. Separately, Jamaica and the United States signed their first Customs Mutual Assistance Agreement this week, aimed mainly at guns and drugs, according to the Gleaner.

What this could mean (analysis)

The BOJ faces a hard balance. Rebuilding after Melissa requires spending, and spending pushes up prices; higher rates cool prices but make it costlier for families and small businesses to borrow and recover. Some will argue the bank should have moved sooner; others will worry it is squeezing an economy still finding its feet. Both concerns deserve a hearing.

What to watch next week

Watch for whether commercial banks and building societies adjust loan rates, how the government’s reconstruction budget is managed, and early signals ahead of the next BOJ decision on December 18. November inflation figures are due in mid-December.

3. COP31 in Overtime: The Fight Over Two Words, and Why Islands Care

What happened

The COP31 climate summit in Antalya, Türkiye, was scheduled to close on Friday, November 20. Instead it ran into overtime, stuck on a basic question: should the final agreement mention fossil fuels at all? On Thursday, the presidency released a second draft of the main decision that was about half the length of the first and dropped every reference to fossil fuels, coal, oil and gas, AFP reported, as published by the Jamaica Observer. A US$120 billion adaptation finance target sought by developing countries was also removed.

The earlier draft, released around Monday, had called for a faster phase-out of fossil fuels and an end to inefficient fossil fuel subsidies, Health Policy Watch reported. The new version promoted carbon capture technology and turned a proposed goal of raising electricity’s share of energy use to 35 percent by 2035 into a voluntary option. The European Union warned that the text risked turning the summit into “a fossil summit,” according to AFP.

Table comparing the first and second COP31 draft decisions: length cut from 18 to 9 pages, fossil fuel phase-out language removed, the US$120 billion adaptation finance target dropped, the 35 percent electricity goal made voluntary, and the call to phase out inefficient fossil fuel subsidies removed.
How the summit’s main text changed in three days, according to news reports. Graphic: cbeharie.com. Data: AFP via Jamaica Observer; Health Policy Watch; AP via PBS NewsHour.

Who is pushing back

Small island states led the objections. The Alliance of Small Island States (AOSIS) warned that the summit would fail without stronger commitments. “We cannot delude ourselves into thinking meaningful progress is being made,” the group said, as reported by Trinidad and Tobago’s CNC3. Fiji’s climate minister Lynda Tabuya, speaking for Pacific island states, told the Fiji Times that the text was not a meaningful response to the world overshooting 1.5°C of warming, and called carbon capture a red line.

A coalition led by Panama and France also demanded stronger language. Panama’s representative, Juan Carlos Navarro, said bluntly, “we simply will not put up with it,” according to UN News. On the other side, oil producers including Saudi Arabia have resisted phase-out wording. The summit’s president, Türkiye’s environment minister Murat Kurum, said negotiators were close to the finish line but not there yet, Al Jazeera reported, while Australia’s Chris Bowen, who leads the negotiations, promised to keep working as long as it takes.

The Caribbean angle

For Jamaica, this is not an abstract debate. A year after a Category 5 hurricane, the island is still counting the cost of a warming world. Jamaica’s delegation is led by Minister Matthew Samuda, with climate envoy Professor Dale Webber, according to a Gleaner commentary by Elizabeth Morgan. Before the summit, CARICOM named Samuda to co-lead its negotiations on adaptation and on the very decision text now in dispute, WINN reported (background, November 6).

There was one concrete regional win. A US$10 million project funded by the Global Environment Facility and led by the development bank CAF was launched at COP31 to tackle sargassum seaweed, with Jamaica among seven participating countries, the Gleaner reported.

What this could mean (analysis)

Climate deals require consensus, which means a single determined bloc can water down a text. For island states, weak language on fossil fuels and finance translates into more expensive adaptation later, from sea walls to stronger roofs. Supporters of the presidency argue that a modest deal is better than none; critics say a deal that avoids naming the main cause of warming is a step backward from earlier summits.

What to watch next week

As of Saturday morning, talks were still deadlocked and a third draft was expected, AFP reported via Business Recorder. Watch whether any fossil fuel wording returns, whether Panama or others formally object, how adaptation and loss and damage finance end up, and how CARICOM and Jamaica respond once the gavel falls.

4. Three Leaders, One Table: The Shenzhen Summit

What happened

On Thursday, November 19, on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in Shenzhen, China, President Xi Jinping hosted the first-ever meeting of the leaders of the United States, China and Russia. The Associated Press, via the Jamaica Gleaner, reported that the gathering produced no breakthroughs on the wars in Ukraine or the Middle East, and looked more like a photo opportunity than a historic turning point.

The three leaders did sign a short four-point statement titled the “Declaration toward Peace.” According to the full text published by China’s CGTN, they committed to reforming the United Nations, said they plan to increase production and supply of refined petroleum products, stressed state consent and immunity for officials in dealings with the International Criminal Court, and affirmed that “a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought.” They promised a dialogue on nuclear risks, but set no date.

Infographic summarizing the four points of the November 19, 2026 Shenzhen Declaration toward Peace (UN reform, refined petroleum supply, limits on international courts, nuclear risk dialogue) and listing what the text does not mention: the war in Ukraine, the war involving Iran, sanctions and Taiwan.
The declaration is notable as much for what it leaves out as for what it says. Graphic: cbeharie.com. Data: CGTN full text; NPR.

Who wanted what

Each leader came with his own priorities, NPR reported. President Trump wanted to talk about reducing nuclear weapons, since the last US-Russia arms control treaty, New START, expired in February, and about keeping Iran from building a bomb. President Putin sought an end to the Ukraine war on terms favorable to Moscow. President Xi focused on China’s standing as host and peacemaker. “The world is at peace when great powers live in harmony,” Xi said, Al Jazeera reported, citing Xinhua.

Back in Washington on Friday, Trump called the trip “one of the most successful presidential visits to Asia in American history,” CBS News reported, and said he and Xi had agreed on guardrails for artificial intelligence, without giving details. Chinese state media also said Trump told Xi the US does not support Taiwan independence; the White House had not confirmed that account, IBTimes UK reported.

The skeptics

Arms control experts were unimpressed. “We need more than diplomatic theater and photo opportunities,” said Daryl Kimball of the Arms Control Association, according to AP. Ukraine’s foreign minister Andriy Sybiha said, “Shenzhen is not the Yalta Putin dreams of,” LIGA.net reported, a reference to the 1945 meeting where great powers carved up postwar Europe. On the same day, Ukraine’s allies met in Berlin, and Putin later said there was no prospect of immediate talks with Kyiv, The National reported.

Why it matters for small states

No country outside the three was at the table, and smaller nations were uneasy that their interests could be decided without them, Al Jazeera noted. The backdrop matters for the Caribbean too. AFP, via The Star, reported that Washington imposed new tariffs of up to 12.5 percent on 60 economies earlier this year after the US Supreme Court struck down many earlier ones. And any genuine increase in global fuel supply would matter to import-dependent islands, where, as the BOJ noted this week, commodity prices feed directly into the cost of living.

What this could mean (analysis)

A meeting of the world’s three biggest military powers is, in itself, a signal that they prefer talking to escalation. That is worth something. But declarations without dates or targets are easy to sign. The real test is whether the nuclear dialogue begins, whether fuel supply actually rises, and whether Ukraine and Europe are brought into any settlement rather than presented with one.

What to watch next week

Watch for any date or format for the promised nuclear talks, Russia’s response to Ukraine’s strikes on the Crimean bridge, follow-up from the Berlin meeting of Ukraine’s allies, and whether Washington clarifies its position on Taiwan. Trump and Xi are due to meet again at the G20 summit in Florida in December.

5. A First at the World Court: Myanmar Found Responsible for Genocide

What happened

On Thursday, November 19, the International Court of Justice in The Hague ruled that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya, a mostly Muslim minority, during the military’s 2017 campaign in northern Rakhine State. It is the first time the court has found a state responsible for genocide, the Associated Press reported, via the Jamaica Gleaner. The judgment, read by court President Yuji Iwasawa, took nearly three hours.

The core finding passed by 9 votes to 6, according to the court’s press release. The judges found that Myanmar’s security forces killed members of the group, caused serious bodily and mental harm, and imposed measures to prevent births, and they rejected Myanmar’s argument that it was fighting insurgents. The court did not, however, accept The Gambia’s claim that Myanmar directly and publicly incited genocide.

Stacked bar chart of International Court of Justice votes in The Gambia v. Myanmar on November 19, 2026: 9 to 6 that Myanmar committed genocide and failed to prevent it, 11 to 4 that it failed to punish genocide and breached a 2020 order to preserve evidence, 13 to 2 that it must investigate and prosecute, 10 to 5 on restitution and compensation, and 14 to 1 that it did not directly incite genocide.
The court was divided on the central question but more united on Myanmar’s duty to punish and prosecute. Graphic: cbeharie.com. Data: International Court of Justice press release No. 2026/30.

What the court ordered

Myanmar must pass laws giving effect to the Genocide Convention, investigate and prosecute suspects, provide guarantees that it will not happen again, and make restitution, including enabling the safe, voluntary and dignified return of refugees, UN News reported. Compensation will be set in a later phase, and Myanmar must report to the court within two years. The judgment is final and cannot be appealed, but the court has no police force; non-compliance can only be referred to the UN Security Council.

Background

The 2017 crackdown killed about 10,000 Rohingya and drove more than 730,000 across the border into Bangladesh, Al Jazeera reported. About 1.2 million Rohingya now live in Bangladesh, mostly in camps around Cox’s Bazar. The case was brought in 2019 by The Gambia, a small West African nation, with backing from the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation. In 2007, the court found that Serbia had failed to prevent the Srebrenica genocide but did not find Serbia itself responsible, AP noted.

Reactions

Myanmar’s military-led government said the ruling “came as a great disappointment” and maintained that its operations were limited counter-terrorism, Reuters reported. The Gambian presidency called it “a historic day for international justice,” according to Demócrata. Bangladesh welcomed the verdict and called for pressure on Myanmar to allow refugees to return, The Business Standard reported.

For Rohingya survivors, the verdict was both vindication and a reminder of how much remains undone. “Recognition alone is not enough,” an 18-year-old refugee told NPR. Former UN special rapporteur Yanghee Lee put it this way: “justice has been decided, but not yet delivered,” Al Jazeera reported. Britain said it would expel Myanmar’s defense attaché and sought an urgent Security Council meeting.

What this could mean (analysis)

The ruling shows that international law can be invoked by small states, not only great powers. The Gambia, a country of a few million people, carried this case for seven years. For Caribbean nations that rely on a rules-based order rather than military might, that is a meaningful precedent. Enforcement, though, depends on the Security Council, where geopolitics often decides more than law.

What to watch next week

Watch for closed Security Council consultations requested by Britain, with a private meeting set for December 7, HNGN reported, and for any response from China and Russia. Other genocide cases still pending before the court include South Africa v. Israel and Ukraine v. Russia.


Closing Reflection: Faithful in Little Things

A reflection from cbeharie.com.

Jesus once told his disciples, “He who is faithful in what is least is faithful also in much” (Luke 16:10, NKJV). It is a quiet verse, easy to pass over, but this week’s news kept returning to it.

A box of crackers past its date, a bag of rice left to the weevils, a receipt that was never filled in: none of these seems large on its own. Yet together they shape whether a nation trusts the people charged with helping it in its worst hour. The same is true of interest rates set carefully month by month, of promises written into climate texts, and of the slow, patient work of a small country pursuing justice for a persecuted people across seven long years.

This verse does not tell us which party to blame for ODPEM’s failures, or how exactly the world should phase out oil. Faithful people disagree on those questions. What it does remind us is that stewardship is tested in small things, in the record kept, the promise honored and the neighbor not forgotten when no one is watching.

So this weekend, let us pray for families still waiting for repairs, for leaders who must decide hard things, and for the Rohingya, who have waited so long to be believed. And let us look at the small things entrusted to us, and be faithful in them.

Walk good, and God bless.


Sources

This briefing was prepared with AI research and writing assistance under Colin Beharie’s editorial direction. Every fact links to its original source. Spot an error? See our Sources & Corrections policy.

Want the useful version every morning? Get The Morning Three free: three stories, three lessons, about four minutes.

THE BEHARIE LETTER · EVERY SUNDAY

Enjoyed this? Get one idea worth thinking about every Sunday.

Business, leadership, faith, culture and life between Jamaica and Norway. Free gift when you join: 20 Jamaican Phrases Every Visitor Should Know.

Prefer something daily? Try The Morning Three. No spam, unsubscribe any time.


Discover more from Colin Beharie

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.